My Carnival Magic Review: Is a western Caribbean cruise for you? The jury is out and I believe there are far better cruise itineraries then a western Caribbean cruise. The Carnival Jubilee offers 7-day Western Caribbean cruise from Galveston, Texas, with itineraries including Cozumel, Costa Maya, and Mahogany Bay (Roatan). I recently went on this 7-day Eastern Caribbean cruise with the following port schedule:
- Day 1: Galveston, TX (Departure at 3:30 PM).
- Day 2: Fun Day at Sea.
- Day 3: Cozumel, Mexico (Arrive 9:00 AM, Depart 5:00 PM).
- Day 4: Costa Maya, Mexico (Arrive 8:00 AM, Depart 5:00 PM).
- Day 5: Mahogany Bay, Roatan (Arrive 7:30 AM, Depart 4:00 PM).
- Day 6: Fun Day at Sea.
- Day 7: Fun Day at Sea.
- Day 8: Galveston, TX (Arrives 8:00 AM).
Let me get into detail with my review of not only the ship, but the itinerary. This is not my first cruise, so can say that I have other cruises to compare to this cruise. Based on mostly the shore excursions, I will skip a western Caribbean cruise in the future. Search for your perfect cruise here.
Cabin Deck 12 Spa Suites Cabin Rating: 2/5
With its soothing décor and outdoor ocean breeze, there’s no better place to warm up for your spa appointment or wind down after your treatment than on your Cloud 9 Spa Balcony. Every room onboard included a dedicated stateroom attendant, plenty of closet and drawer space, an in-room safe, TV, and mini fridge. Hot water was out at least 3 days of the cruise and there was a distince smell down our corridor, like mold or mildew. Outlets were sparse, with two single outlets for use.
Amenities exclusive to Cloud 9 Spa staterooms and suites:
- Unique welcome ritual
- Priority spa reservations
- Unlimited use of Thermal Suites, plus scrub kit
- Two complimentary fitness classes (per guest)
- Complimentary body composition analysis
- Exclusive discounts on treatments during port days
- Cloud 9 Spa bathrobes and slippers
- ELEMIS in-stateroom bath products
Carnival Atlantic Deck Dining Dining Rating 3/5
We had the early dining, which in my opinon, is the best time for dinner. You are assigned a table, which will be your table every night. Now I knew everybody at the table, so it was a good experience in that aspect. Breakfast and lunch dining is a little different allowing you to sit at different tables. Dinner includes an appetizer, main course, and dessert. There are several options for each and they vary each night. You can also order more then one of each. Several at my table did this. The portions are not super big, so you can explore. Only problem is, if you order 2 or 3 appetizers, they are going to bring you all three… at once! They appeared to want to get you in and out. The staff was friendly, just make sure you let them know everything you want up front. You will probably, most likely not get the opportunity later.
Other Restaurant Options:
Bluelguana Cantina Rating: 5/5
The food here is great. Just expect there to be a line. A lot of people opt in for this lunch/dinner option. A bit of a wait but worth it. The BlueIguana Cantin features freshly made tacos and burritos stuffed to your specifications. Throw in homemade tortillas and salsa, and you have a yummy meal. There breakfast tacos and burritos as well.
Guy’s Burger Joint Review: 4/5
Only reason I give it a 4/5 is because of the long wait. It is popular, so always a long line and not a lot of seating in the close vacinity. This cool poolside spot for hot burgers and hand-cut fries is awesome. There are a few different burger options and a loaded condiment bar. Don’t miss out on a Guy’s burger! There is no additional charge for Guy’s Burger Joint.
Lido Marketplace Review 3/5
We ate here almost every morning for breakfast, and sometimes for lunch. At breakfast, the best option is the omlet station where they will cook your eggs to order. You’ll find BBQ, a deli counter, salad bar, bakery, vary meats and cheeses, asian food, italian choices and much more for lunch and dinner. I find that when there is such a wide variety, and it’s buffet style, not everything is going to be “that great”. The cook to order omlet was great, the bacon and sausage and other sides had been sitting, and there was just no freshness there. The Lido Marketplace as a whole, just did not have any wow factor or freshness factor.
Chibang Review: 5/5
They’ve brought together favorite dishes from the two cuisines, into an amazing menu with Mexican and Chinese. We each ordered two different menu choices (not big portions) and then just shared. It was fast, friendly and very yummy. Enjoy a casual lunch that features noodle and burrito bowls based on their favorite ingredients from both of these worlds. There is no additional charge for Chibang.
Cloud 9 Spa & Fitness Center Review 2/5
The Carnival Jubilee features a Cloud 9 Spa and Fitness Center offers a range of relaxation and wellness options. The Cloud 9 Spa provides various treatments and therapies, including massages, facials, and access to a thermal suite with a thalassotherapy pool. The Fitness Center is equipped with Life Fitness equipment, including cardio machines and free weights. I found the fitness room to be great. I could do the workouts I normally do at the gym here. Getting there early is the key. I used the thermal suites almost daily and they spontaneouusly worked…. some never, some maybe once. The first two days of the cruise, the jacuzzi was not available. This was the only disappointment.
The Serenity Deck Review: 5/5
This is an adults-only lounge area, with two large hot tubs and pool, showers, a bar, luxury padded loungers, chairs and shaded areas. Hours: 8:00am-11:00pm. Guests must be 21 years or older. There is a complimentary salad station during meal times. Great place for couples to go without having the pool/jacuzzi’s overrun by children.
The Punchliner Comedy Club Review: 5/5
Carnival Jubilee has its own Punchliner Comedy Club in the Grand Central zone, and up on stage you’ll find some real pros who know how to wedge a little laughter into anyone’s evening. You can count on these comedians to not hold back either. Since some of them get up and say exactly what’s on their mind, there are also family-friendly performances. I saw every comedy show I could and I laughed…. a lot! The comedy shows should not be missed. Get there at least 30 minutes before the show for a good seat.
Shore Excursions Review: 2/5
Was not really impressed with any of the shore excurions. A lot of traffic and driving time to an from beaches. Beaches were sub par type beaches with low alcohol drinks for the open bars. I would’nt do another western Caribbean cruise just because of the ports. I’d say to skip it and do any other, with the eastern being my favorite. Especailly at Roatan, just do the short walk to Mahogany Bay, which is still not high on my best beaches list. Skip the expensive shore excursions. I wish we would have done that here. We were able to spend an hour at Mahogany Bay after our shore excursion ended. It was 500% nicer and free.
Visit our “How to Choose A Cruise” right for you, for some tips on picking the right cruise for you. I have taken 3 cruises so far this year so look for my other reviews. I enjoy them, but cruising is not the perfect vacation for everyone. Considering a cruise, or is a cruise right for you? Click here for considerations into taking a cruise. Find your cruise here.
Search For Your Perfect Cruise Here
Related Posts
Your Guide to the Best Eastern Mediterranean Cruises & Insider Secrets- The Best Cruise Guide: How to Find Your Perfect Cruise
- The Best Guide to Rhine River Cruises
- The Best Essentials For Your Alaska Cruise You’ll Love
- The Best Cruise Essentials: Pack Light and Cruise Better
- The Most Important Cruise Safety Tips
This was such a thorough and honest review—thank you, Leahrae! ???? It’s super helpful to hear the good and the not-so-great parts, especially for those of us trying to decide if the Western Caribbean is worth it.
I’m surprised about the spa issues and the moldy smell in the corridors—that would definitely put a damper on the experience, especially in a spa suite. But it’s great to hear the Punchliner Comedy Club and Serenity Deck were total hits. Laughter and relaxation sound like cruise essentials to me!
I’m also glad you shared the truth about the shore excursions. It’s easy to get swept up booking pricey tours, so your advice to skip some and just enjoy Mahogany Bay is golden.
Out of curiosity, which Eastern Caribbean ports would you say are your favorites? And would you cruise Carnival again despite the hiccups?
Thanks again for sharing your insights—it makes planning a cruise way less overwhelming!
I have and will cruise on Carnival again, just not on an old ship. I just cruised on the Jubilee and it was fantastic! My three all time favorite cruise ports are San Juan, St. Thomas and St. Maarten. San Juan boasts a well-preserved Old San Juan with colorful colonial architecture, forts like Castillo San Felipe del Morro, and a lively atmosphere with salsa bars and restaurants. St. Thomas is known for its stunning beaches like Magen’s Bay and offers a blend of natural beauty. St. Maarten is divided between French and Dutch territories, offering a blend of European charm and Caribbean culture. Philipsburg (Dutch side) and Marigot (French side) are popular ports with shopping, beaches, and diverse culinary experiences.
Thank you so much for this detailed and honest review! I really appreciate how you balanced the pros and cons across so many aspects of the Carnival Jubilee experience, from dining to shore excursions. It is refreshing to see a candid perspective that goes beyond the usual “just fun” cruise hype.
Your insights on the Cloud 9 Spa cabin were especially eye opening. I did not realise issues like hot water outages and moldy smell could be such a downer in what is supposed to be a relaxing space. The amenities sound great on paper, but it’s those small details that really affect the overall experience.
I also found your dining breakdown super helpful. The contrast between places like BlueIguana Cantina and Lido Marketplace really stood out. It sounds like quality and freshness vary a lot depending on where you eat onboard. And I totally get the dilemma with the early dining option and getting multiple appetizers served all at once. It must feel like a food overload and a loosening of the belt needed!
Your point about the shore excursions and the western Caribbean itinerary was very telling. It seems like a lot of cruising experiences can be defined by the ports, not just the ship itself. I am curious if you have any favorite eastern Caribbean ports or itineraries you.could recommend instead?
Lastly, the Serenity Deck and Punchliner Comedy Club sound like fantastic spots to unwind, especially for those looking to escape the usual family pool chaos or enjoy some good laughs.
Looking forward to reading your other cruise reviews and maybe even making a plan for a cruise vacation!
Yes, the Serenity Deck and the Punchliner Club were the highlights! I have done a few Eastern Caribbean cruises, and my favorite ports will always be St. Thomas, St. Maarten,Grand Turk, and San Juan. I would include these ports for sure, book early and pick your shore excursions early, as the good shore excursions fill up very quickly.
Your site really made me think of the details I need to consider when planning a cruise. I always understood Carnival to be a good choice for a cruise with a decant price tag. I am curious if you had a better experience with Carnival on a different ship? If so, which ship was it and was it with Carnival?
Hi There Stella. Yes, Carnival can be a decent choice for a cruise and they do have really competive pricing. Most recently I took a cruise on the Carnival Jubilee. That was a really good experience. The ship is fairly new, so everything was working with no issues.
Leahrae, thank you for such an honest and detailed review—this was super helpful! I really appreciate the way you broke everything down by category and shared both highs and lows.
A few thoughts and questions came to mind as I read:
???? Western Caribbean vs. Other Itineraries: You mentioned preferring the Eastern Caribbean—totally curious, which Eastern ports have stood out to you the most and why? Would love a quick comparison if you have one.
???? Dining Pace: The main dining room experience sounds a bit rushed—do you feel that’s typical across Carnival ships, or did it feel specific to the Jubilee?
???? Shore Excursions: That shore excursion feedback is so valuable. Do you think a DIY approach (like grabbing a taxi or exploring on foot) would’ve worked better at some of these ports? Any tips for first-timers trying to plan outside of Carnival’s packages?
???? Comedy Shows: Loved hearing that the Punchliner Comedy Club was a highlight! Were there any standout comedians or specific shows that really stuck with you?
This review definitely makes me rethink my next cruise itinerary.
You’re right—cruising isn’t always one-size-fits-all, but posts like this help make more informed choices.
Thanks again!
Hi Raymon, glad you enjoyed my post. Here are the best Eastern Caribbean Ports:
San Juan, Puerto Rico:.Opens in new tabA vibrant city with historical sites like Old San Juan, forts, and colorful buildings. St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands:.Opens in new tabKnown for beautiful beaches like Magens Bay, duty-free shopping, and the charming town of Charlotte Amalie. St. Maarten/St. Martin:.Opens in new tabAn island with a dual nationality, offering a blend of French and Dutch cultures, beautiful beaches, and lively nightlife. Grand Turk, Turks and Caicos:.Opens in new tabA smaller island with a focus on relaxation, stunning beaches, and a large cruise port area. Nassau, Bahamas:.Opens in new tabA bustling city with a vibrant culture, historic sites, and access to beautiful beaches and resorts. Tortola, British Virgin Islands:.Opens in new tabKnown for its sailing, stunning beaches like Cane Garden Bay, and relaxed atmosphere. St. Kitts:.Opens in new tabOffers a mix of history, beaches, and natural beauty, with Basseterre as its main port.
As far as dining goes, no that is not typical. I have also been on Royal Caribbean and Disney where dinner is not rushed and a much more pleasant time. As far as the comedians, you know I wish I could remember their names LOL. There was a female (all the rest were male) and she was just hilarious! I bit on the gross side, but she had me busting up continually!
I love cruises and my dream would be to do a cruise like the one that you described in your article! I could perceive that you really enjoy spas and I’m just like you. Complimentary fitness classes would be a bore for me; because I believe that I mus rest when I go on vacation! I’m sorry that you found excursions less interesting because I generally enjoy them and I always find very interesting to discover new cultures.
I generally enjoy shore excurisions as well. But with a Western Caribbean cruise…which involves Mexico ports are generally, in my opinion, not necessarily the greatest. Really depends on the cruise line.
Hello!
This is a really insightful review! You’ve painted a vivid picture of Carnival Jubilee—it’s clear this ship brings the energy with its vibrant entertainment lineup, immersive deck parties, and diverse dining options. I can almost see the roller coaster and feel the buzz around venues like Shaq’s chicken and ChiBang.
I appreciate how you addressed the practical side too—crowds, queues, and some cramped spaces aren’t to be overlooked. It sounds like Jubilee is a fantastic pick for those who love nonstop fun and don’t mind the hustle. On the flip side, it may feel overwhelming if you’re seeking relaxation or more intimate settings. For travelers like me, who enjoy lively atmospheres but also value smoother logistics and quieter corners, this review is invaluable.
Thanks for laying it all out so clearly—it really helps in deciding if Jubilee matches the vibe, you’re after!
Angela M 🙂
Thank you Angela. I agree and generally most Carnival cruises are crowded. Really depends on what cruise you take and where you are going. Cheaper cruises tend to be overly crowded. This was not a pick for me, I just went along. I would not have chosen this particular cruise.
I’ve done both Western and Eastern Caribbean cruises, and I 100% agree—Eastern ports like St. Thomas, San Juan, and Grand Turk feel much more culturally rich or naturally beautiful with less effort. The excursions tend to be smoother and more immersive.
I also once booked a shore excursion in Roatan and ended up regretting it because the beach right near the port (Mahogany Bay) was actually the better experience—no buses, no rushed lunch, just peaceful and scenic. It was a lesson learned.
This review does a great job of showing that a cruise experience is truly a blend of ship quality and destination value. While the Carnival Jubilee appears to hit the mark on food variety, spa offerings, and adult-only spaces, the port critiques are totally valid.
It’s refreshing to hear an honest take that praises the crew and onboard fun (like Punchliner Comedy Club) but isn’t afraid to admit that the shore excursions didn’t live up to expectations. I’d recommend this article to anyone debating between itineraries or trying to decide if they want to try the Jubilee.
If anything, this review proves that Eastern or Southern Caribbean cruises offer more rewarding adventures, while Western might be better suited for first-time cruisers who are mostly in it for the ship itself.
However, i have a few questions about the topic.
Did you try any of the specialty dining options not included in this review, like Bonsai Sushi or Cucina del Capitano (if available)?
Was embarkation and disembarkation at Galveston smooth and timely? How was the crowd flow on sea days?
For future cruisers who might still be curious about the Western itinerary, are there any must-do tips for avoiding the more disappointing excursions?
I totally agree! An eastern or southern Caribbean cruise is much better for sure! I just went on an amazing eatern Caribbean cruise. Only disappointment was that the spa was mostly broke. Jacuzzi was never hot, steam room worked 2 out of 8 days. Other areas in the spad just flat out were not working. The gym was mediocre. Old ship and lots of thens that needed repaired. This was the Carnival Magic. So shore excursions were the only good thing and again Guy’s Burgers LOL.
Thanks for sharing such a detailed review! It’s always helpful to hear firsthand experiences, especially for those of us considering a cruise on the Carnival Jubilee. I appreciate your insights into the dining options—especially your take on Bluelguana Cantina and Chibang! Those sound like must-tries. I’m curious, did you find any standout shore excursions in Cozumel or Roatan that you would recommend? I’m always looking for unique experiences while cruising. Thanks again for the thorough breakdown!
I acutally did not. Problem was also the fact that the really popular shore excursions were all sold out. So, that is another tip. Plan your cruise early, and pick your shore excursions early. That way you can pick shore excursions with a good rating that everyone has said is great. Best way to determine is to really look at the reviews of the shore excursions which are listed right there when you are deciding.
Thanks for sharing an informative article!
This review of the Carnival Jubilee cruise is rich with personal experience, detailed insights, and practical tips, making it a helpful resource for potential cruisers, especially those considering a Western Caribbean itinerary. The clear structure, broken down by ship features and amenities, gives readers a well-rounded understanding of the good and the not-so-great aspects of the trip.
Looking forward to more posts!
Keep up the good work!
Thank S.J. I have more cruise reviews ahead 🙂 Better ones for sure. Thanks for visiting beach travel destinations and taking the time to leave me comments.
It sounds like you went into this cruise with an open mind but walked away feeling a bit underwhelmed by the itinerary, especially the shore excursions. That’s totally fair, while destinations like Cozumel and Costa Maya have their charm, they can start to feel a bit “same-y” if you’ve done a few cruises. And Mahogany Bay, while beautiful, doesn’t always offer the depth of culture or adventure that other ports might.
You make a good point by highlighting the value of experience, first-time cruisers might find the Western Caribbean exciting, but seasoned travelers like you and I, might be craving something with more variety or cultural richness. It would be great to hear more about what specifically didn’t meet expectations: Were the excursions too touristy? Was the time in port too short? Or did the destinations just lack that “wow” factor?
Also, your detailed day-by-day breakdown is super helpful for anyone considering this itinerary it sets clear expectations, especially the three full sea days, which not everyone loves. I know I get bored quickly!
Would love to hear what cruise itineraries you do recommend instead. Eastern Caribbean? Mediterranean? Alaska? Sounds like you’ve got some great comparisons to share.
Kind regards,
Martin
Hi Martin, and thank you for visiting beach travel destinations as well as your thoughtful insights. I would have to say the ports just did not have any wow factor, and yes they did seem “same-y”. I went with friends who chose this cruise. So for me, it was going along with the friends, but I don’t particularly like a western caribbean cruise. And yes, the 3 full sea days is a LOT and roaming the ship all day tends to get boring in my opinion. I do have other cruises I plan on reviewing (went on 4 this year), so keep reading 🙂